
A dental check-up, a pair of glasses, six sessions of physiotherapy: these are the bills an employee health cash plan was built for. Alongside it, most benefits packages offer an employee assistance programme and, higher up the pay scale, private medical insurance. They look similar on a benefits portal, yet HMRC taxes each one differently, and a fourth service, occupational health, is the one you are most likely to meet without choosing it.
Four health benefits side by side
| Benefit | What it pays for | Tax if the employer pays |
|---|---|---|
| Health cash plan | Routine costs refunded up to annual limits | Benefit in kind, reported on P11D |
| Employee assistance programme | Confidential counselling and information line | Exempt if the conditions are met |
| Private medical insurance | Private diagnosis and treatment of acute conditions | Benefit in kind, reported on P11D |
| Occupational health | Fitness-for-work assessments and advice | Not a personal benefit; up to £500 of recommended return-to-work treatment exempt |
The pattern is simple: insurance that pays out for you personally is taxable, welfare counselling generally is not.
How an employee health cash plan pays back everyday costs
A health cash plan is a low-cost insurance that refunds part or all of what you spend on routine care. You pay the dentist, optician or physiotherapist yourself, send the receipt, and the plan reimburses you up to a limit for each category of treatment. Limits reset every year, and many plans set them in levels, so a higher premium buys higher limits.
Take a worked example. Your plan has an optical limit of £150 and you buy glasses for £210. You claim £150 and pay the remaining £60. In the same year a dental limit of £100 covers two check-ups and a hygienist visit at £95 in total, so the full amount comes back.
The tax position
When the employer pays, a health cash plan counts as medical insurance, and medical insurance is not on HMRC’s list of exempt medical benefits. The employer reports the cost on your P11D and pays Class 1A National Insurance on it at 15% for 2026/27. You pay income tax on the value: on a £120 premium that is £24 for a basic-rate taxpayer and £48 at the higher rate. Scotland’s income tax bands differ, so the figure there depends on the Scottish rate you pay.
A few items stay tax-free whoever arranges them, including one health screening or medical check a year, eye tests for staff who use screens, and flu vaccinations. An employee health cash plan you buy yourself from net pay, often through a voluntary benefits portal, has no tax or reporting attached.
What an EAP covers
An employee assistance programme (EAP) is usually a 24-hour phone line with access to short-term counselling, plus information on debt, work problems, bereavement and family matters. HMRC’s welfare counselling exemption under section 210 of the Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003 means the employer pays no tax or National Insurance on it, and nothing goes on your P11D, if three conditions hold:
- the counselling deals with welfare issues such as stress, ill health, bereavement, abuse or relationship problems;
- it is available to all employees;
- it does not include tax advice, legal advice, leisure advice or financial advice other than help with debt.
Since 6 April 2020, counselling that is also medical treatment, such as Cognitive Behavioural Therapy or Interpersonal Therapy, is covered by the exemption as well. The tighter rules sit around the edges. The exemption does not apportion, so an EAP that bundles in bespoke legal advice can lose it on every service. An employee assistance programme provided through salary sacrifice is not exempt at all and has to be reported at the higher of the salary given up or the cost.
If you run the scheme
Ask the provider for a written list of every service in the EAP, and check family access against the HMRC conditions: no separate family helpline and no one-to-one face-to-face counselling for dependants. If any component falls outside the exemption, HMRC suggests splitting it into a separate arrangement so the core counselling stays tax-free.
Private medical insurance and the P11D
Private medical insurance (PMI) pays for private diagnosis and treatment, mostly of acute conditions that respond to treatment. When an employer pays the premium under a group policy, HMRC charges the cost of that premium as a benefit in kind under section 203.
Suppose your share of the group premium is £1,400 a year. As a basic-rate taxpayer you pay £280 in income tax; at 40% it is £560. Your employer pays Class 1A of £210 at 15%. Cover for a partner or children is usually added at extra cost, and that cost is taxed on you too.
Until now the benefit has been reported on form P11D after the tax year ends, and your tax code collects the tax. That is changing. HMRC has published that employer-provided medical benefits are in the first phase of mandatory payrolling from April 2027, together with company cars, vans and fuel. Most other benefits follow from April 2028. From then on, private medical insurance will show on your payslip each month instead of arriving as a tax code adjustment.
Salary sacrifice does not help here: medical insurance under a salary sacrifice arrangement is still reported. The salary sacrifice calculator and the flexible benefits hub explain which benefits keep a tax advantage when you give up pay.
Occupational health: the service you do not choose
Occupational health advisers assess whether someone is fit for their role and what adjustments would help, after a long absence or when a health problem affects work. You do not sign up for it; your manager or HR refers you. The report to your employer covers capacity and adjustments, not your full medical history.
Treatment that occupational health recommends can be paid for tax-free. HMRC exempts up to £500 of medical treatment per employee per year, provided the employee has been unfit for work, or absent, for at least 28 consecutive days and a health professional recommended it. Physiotherapy after back surgery is a typical use.
What employers should check before renewing
Health benefits sit next to insured cover for long absences, so review them together with your group risk benefits. Before renewal, confirm which benefits will go through payroll from April 2027 and whether your payroll software can handle it. Check that the EAP still meets every exemption condition after any new services were added, and that cash plan limits match what staff actually claim for. The wellbeing hub covers the support that sits around these benefits. One year of anonymised claims data from the cash plan provider will show which categories staff use and which limits nobody reaches.